Thermodynamic elucidation and prediction of chemical synergism in complex chemical processes

Strategic priority

V. Innovative technologies, sustainable energy, digitalization

Strategic direction

Fundamental research in physics, chemistry, mathematics

Code
24.80012.5007.19SE
Duration
2024-2025
Project manager
Abstract

The rigorous thermodynamic study will elucidate the phenomenon of synergism in complex chemical processes. Synergism is often explained differently depending on the chemical structures of the reactants, the energy of the processes, etc. Chemical interactions depend on the chemical composition of the reaction mixture and/or the temperature and/or pressure. Chemical synergism, due to chemical equilibria in the flow, is governed by the intensity of these three main thermodynamic parameters. The phenomenon of synergism is observed only at certain values ​​of temperature and pressure and at a certain ratio of the concentrations of the components of the reactant mixture.

The authors of the project will demonstrate that in complex chemical processes, the common characteristic of synergism is the formation of a mixed compound or complex, stable over a certain period of time. Knowledge of this common characteristic will allow a deeper understanding of the phenomenon and the prediction of the necessary synergistic effects. Known synergistic processes, studied with physicochemical methods, will be analyzed in terms of the formation of a mixed compound. Many reactions form mixed compounds without a registered synergistic effect. The lack of synergistic effect can be explained by the lack of measurement of a certain quantity.

In the future, software programs for searching for synergistic effects will include the possibility of the formation of mixed compounds. The discovery of a synergistic effect as a result of a chemical process will take into account the formation of a mixed compound or complex. The relationships deduced in this project will be useful for the search and design of new synergistic processes. These systems will be used in various fields of chemical and biochemical research, in analytical chemistry, pharmacology, pharmaceutical industry, medical and synthetic organic chemistry.

Synergistic mixtures are expected to represent the future for "new reagents", replacing the expensive development of reagents that require regulation. Future research will focus on the isolation and characterization of mixed compounds, providing more detailed thermodynamic and kinetic knowledge, supported by theoretical calculations, since the current understanding is based only on empirical observations.

Results, activities

Summary of the activity and results obtained in 2024

The goal of this project is to investigate synergism in complex chemical processes through a rigorous thermodynamic approach, with applications in chemistry, biochemistry, and the pharmaceutical, medical, and chemical industries. The research focuses on elucidating synergistic interactions, identifying conditions that favor or inhibit this phenomenon, and promoting synergistic mixtures as sustainable alternatives to costly individual reactants. By deepening the understanding of synergism and antagonism phenomena, the project aims to develop efficient chemical processes with a reduced environmental impact.

A comprehensive methodology has been developed, based on standard thermodynamic data, mass balance equations, and experimental observations, to evaluate the conditions under which synergism and antagonism manifest during extraction processes. Theoretical and experimental studies targeted well-documented systems, such as Zn²⁺-thenoyltrifluoroacetone-TBP, providing detailed insights into the distribution of chemical species between the aqueous and organic (benzene) phases as a function of pH, temperature, and chemical composition. The analysis of these systems allowed for the definition of a synergism index (SI) to quantify the phenomenon and identify the conditions triggering the transition from synergism to antagonism.

Advanced thermodynamic calculations and theoretical simulations provided an in-depth understanding of the behavior of selected systems, validating the proposed methodology through the correlation of results with experimental data from the literature. The findings offer a robust foundation for predicting synergism and antagonism phenomena under various experimental conditions, such as the chemical composition and pH of heterogeneous liquid-liquid systems.

The applicability of the results spans multiple fields:

  1. Optimization of industrial processes – The use of synergistic mixtures can significantly reduce production costs and increase the efficiency of chemical processes.
  2. Development of new reagents and products – Chemical synergism offers a viable alternative to expensive reactants, fostering innovation in the pharmaceutical and chemical industries.
  3. Sustainability – Reducing resource consumption and environmental impact through the use of synergistic mixtures instead of less efficient conventional processes.

The project also included dissemination of the results at three international conferences: MARBLUE 2024 (Constanța, Romania), IasiCHEM 2024 (Iași, Romania), and SIMI 2024 (Constanța, Romania) and one national conference with international participation (Tiraspol 2024). Participation in these events facilitated the exchange of ideas and collaborations with experts in the field, advancing research in chemical synergism.

By applying this methodology, the project findings provide an innovative framework for the design and implementation of sustainable chemical processes with significant implications in analytical chemistry, pharmaceuticals, biochemistry, and synthetic organic chemistry. These contributions support the development of a sustainable model for resource utilization and environmental impact reduction, addressing current challenges in chemical and industrial research.

Summary of the activity and results obtained in 2025

The aim of the project was to investigate chemical synergism in complex chemical processes through a rigorous thermodynamic approach, with applications in chemistry, biochemistry, environmental science, and the pharmaceutical and medical fields. The research focused on elucidating the mechanisms of synergistic and antagonistic interactions, identifying the conditions that promote or inhibit these effects, and promoting synergistic mixtures as sustainable alternatives to costly individual reagents. By developing predictive models, the project sought to optimize chemical processes while reducing environmental impact.

The central element of the methodology was the introduction of the synergistic coefficient (SC), a quantitative thermodynamic parameter that enables the clear identification, comparison, and direct quantification of synergistic and antagonistic effects. The coefficient describes changes in system stability upon the addition of an auxiliary ligand in the presence of a primary ligand and provides a numerical evaluation of how pH, chemical composition, concentrations, and complex stability influence solubility and phase equilibria. The definition of SC represents an original conceptual contribution, as synergism had previously been described mainly in qualitative or indirect terms.

The methodology was successfully validated in three major application areas. In liquid–liquid metal extraction, thermodynamic modeling enabled prediction of the pH and composition domains where synergism or antagonism occurs and supported rational optimization of extractant combinations, demonstrated on model systems such as Zn²⁺–chelating ligand–TBP. In iron-containing mineral systems, it was shown that siderophores combined with auxiliary ligands (oxalate, phenanthrolines, and sulfonated derivatives) induce strong synergistic dissolution of minerals such as goethite, hematite, and ferrihydrite, with important implications for metal mobility, soil fertility, and environmental remediation. In the pharmaceutical field, studies of “drug–cyclodextrin–auxiliary ligand” systems demonstrated that ternary complex formation significantly enhances the solubility of poorly soluble drugs, enabling rational formulation design and reducing experimental development costs.

Overall, the project outcomes provided a unified, predictive, and transferable theoretical framework with interdisciplinary applicability, contributing to the development of more efficient, sustainable, and competitive chemical technologies.

Publications

Articles in Web of Science and SCOPUS journals

  1. POVAR, I., SPÎNU, O. Forecasting chemical synergism and antagonism by thermodynamic analysis of complex equilibria in metal solvent extraction. In: Chemical Engineering Journal Advances, 2025, 100825. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ceja.2025.100825 (IF 7.1) (Q1 - https://wos-journal.info/journalid/23824)


Articles in proceedings

  1. POVAR, I., SPÎNU, O., BOLOCAN, N. Thermodynamic Analysis of Synergistic Goethite Dissolution Mediated by Siderophore and Oxalate. In: Proceedings of the Earth Systems and Environment Journal Annual Meeting, 28-30 April, 2025, Istanbul, Turkey. (Online publication of the proceedings in the Springer ASTI Book Series (indexed in Scopus)    31 January 2026. https://2025.esev-meeting.org/index.php?p=important-dates) (Anexa 5)
  2. POVAR, I., SPÎNU, O. Analiza termodinamică a efectelor sinergice și antagoniste în extracția metalelor cu solvent. In: Culegerea Conferinţei Ştiinţifico-Practice Internaționale ,,Educație prin cercetare pentru o societate prosperă”, ediția a XII-a, 1-2 martie, 2025, Chișinău, Republica Moldova, pp. 159-164. ISBN 978-9975-48-246-2. https://doi.org/10.46727/c.v1.01-02-03-2025.p159-164


Abstracts

  1. POVAR, I., SPÎNU, O., BOLOCAN, N. Investigație termodinamică a interacțiunilor sinergice și antagoniste în extracția metalelor în sistemele lichid – lichid. In: Book of Abstracts National Conference with International Participation "Natural Sciences in the Dialogue of Generations - 2025", 17-19 September, 2025, Chisinau, Republic of Moldova, p. 161. ISBN 978-9975-62-898-3. https://agarm.md/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/2_Conference_Abstract-book_final-22.09.2025.pdf
  2. BOLOCAN, N., SPÎNU, O., POVAR, I. Quantitative thermodynamic modeling of drug precipitation-dissolution in cyclodextrin-based multicomponent aqueous systems. In: Book of Abstracts of the MEDICINE, MOLECULAR AND ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES congress (MedMolMed 2025), 10-15 November 2025, Chișinău, Republica Moldova, p. 86. https://doi.org/10.19261/medmol25
  3. BOLOCAN, N., SPÎNU, O., POVAR, I. Thermodynamic insights into synergistic enhancement of drug solubility. In: Book of Abstracts of the MEDICINE, MOLECULAR AND ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES congress (MedMolMed 2025), 10-15 November 2025, Chișinău, Republica Moldova, p. 61. https://doi.org/10.19261/medmol25
  4. BOLOCAN, N., POVAR, I., SPÎNU, O. Thermodynamic Framework for Quantifying Drug Precipitation and Solubility in Cyclodextrin-Based Systems. In: The 1st International Electronic Conference on Medicinal Chemistry and Pharmaceutics, 1–30 November 2025, Submission ID: sciforum-151609. https://sciforum.net/paper/view/25769.
  5. POVAR, I., SPÎNU, O., BOLOCAN, N. Fundamentals of synergism in chemistry. In: Book of Abstracts of the 28th International Symposium “Environment and Industry” SIMI 2025, October 23rd-24th 2025, Bucharest, Romania, pp. 122-123. http://doi.org/10.21698/simi.2025.ab53
  6. POVAR, I., SPINU, O. Synergistic chemical interactions of contaminant mixtures in oceanic waters. In: The 2nd International Joint Conference „BLUE GROWTH: CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES FOR THE BLACK SEA”, 23-25th October, 2024, Constanta, Romania, p. 41. https://www.marblue.ro/Book_of_Abstracts_MARBLUE_2024.pdf
  7. POVAR, I., SPINU, O. Thermodynamic analysis and prediction of chemical synergy in complex aqueous chemical processes. In: The 8th International Electronic Conference on Water Sciences, 14–16 October 2024, MDPI: Basel, Switzerland, 18902. https://sciforum.net/paper/view/18902; https://sciforum.net/manuscripts/18902/slides.pdf
  8. POVAR, I., SPINU, O., ZINICOVSCAIA, I. An original thermodynamic assessment of wastewater composition in tannery operations. In: The International Symposium “The Environment and the Industry”, SIMI 2024, September 19-20, Constanta, Romania, pp. 44-45. http://doi.org/10.21698/simi.2024.ab16; https://www.simiecoind.ro/wp-content/uploads/2024/09/16.pdf
  9. POVAR, I., SPINU, O., Visnevschi A. Thermodynamic analysis of synergistic interactions in the optimization of phosphorus recovery from wastewater through struvite crystallization, In: Geo- and bioecological problems of the middle and lower Dniester River Basin: Proceedings of the Scientific Conference with International Participation, Tiraspol, November 15, 2024, Chişinău; Tiraspol: Eco-TIRAS, 2024, 245 p. ISBN 978-9975-89-320-6, p. 165.